College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

Discussion follows showing of abortion documentary

Discussion follows showing of abortion documentary

By Elise Podhajsky

Print this article

Published: Thursday, February 1, 2007

Updated: Monday, July 7, 2008

01.31.07.c.abortiondiaries.lb.jpg

Lyndsey Born

When she went in for an abortion, in the days before Roe v. Wade, the doctor closed the windows and locked the door. He used no painkillers or medical instruments - just a suction bulb. Now, she is unable to have children.

That was one woman's story in the movie "The Abortion Diaries," shown Wednesday night at Manhattan Public Library. The documentary tells the stories of 12 women and their abortion experiences.

About 70 K-State students, faculty and community members attended to learn more about abortion, receive extra credit for their women's studies classes or share ideas.

The film followed how the women became pregnant, how they made the decision to abort, and finally, the relief they felt when it was over.

The opening scene to "The Abortion Diaries" showed a stick figure of a girl clutching her knees, with a thought bubble that read, "If it's so common, why do I feel so alone?"

According to the film, 34 percent of females become pregnant in their teens, one-third of women have abortions, and 1.3 million women will have an abortion this year.

The documentary also said making the decision to abort is not just one decision; there are many decisions.

When the film finished, Betty Banner, director of the Manhattan National Organization for Women chapter, said women should learn more about the issue to "ensure we continue to have rights as women." The focus then switched to the audience's reaction to the film.

Banner explained the discussion was to be a dialogue in which individuals expand their perspectives by listening to and understanding what others had to say, not to convince others their ideas were right or wrong.

What potentially could have been a heated argument was a civil, educational and understanding discussion.

NOW member Debbie Nuss and Angela Hubler, director of the women's studies program, organized the screening.

At first there was silence when Hubler opened the room to discussion. Once the discussion began, however, it soared on for nearly an hour.

Students and community members shared their reactions, stories, and concerns surrounding the issue of abortion.

Phoebe Samelson, representative for the Peggy Bowman Second Chance fund, also participated in the discussion.She said she believes a woman should have the right to choose. She said women need education to prevent unplanned pregnancies.

Samelson said women should know the emergency contraceptive, Plan B, is now available over the counter for women 18 and older.

"It is up to the pharmacist whether or not they wish to dispense Plan B," she said.

After the discussion, some audience members still couldn't see how a woman could consciously make the decision to have an abortion.

Jacob Newell, freshman in pre-psychology, shared his mother's story.

Newell's mother first became pregnant at age 15, again at 18, and finally with him at 25.

"I couldn't imagine life without my siblings," he said.

When the discussion came to a close, Nuss said she was impressed with the turnout and pleased to see people comfortably speaking about the issue.

"This takes a lot of courage," she said.

Jasmine Smith, freshman in open option, expressed her understanding for both sides.

She said she realized that when women get pregnant, they think of both options no matter what they believe.

Smith said she thinks it should be up to women to make choices that are best for their lives, and they should not to be pressured by anyone.

Smith is five months pregnant.

Macy Wendler, junior in apparel and textiles, said seeing abortion from the viewpoint of women rather than just political propaganda was a nice change.

"I thought it was refreshing," she said.