Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Student finds sympathy, understanding at K-State through ‘untherapy’

Published: Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Updated: Wednesday, January 5, 2011 13:01

eye

Photo Illustration by Matt Binter

After six sessions of therapy to change his sexual orientation, Thomas Swanson, who did not want his real name to be used, decided he had had enough of being shocked. The therapy was not working, and he could not bear the thought of more pain. He decided his life was over.

His family lived in a three-story building, and after telling his sister goodbye, he went to the roof and stood at its edge. But before he could jump, his mother burst onto the roof.

"My mom ran onto the roof crying and said ‘I will love you again, if you'll just change,'" Swanson said.

He said those words were heartbreaking because his mother acknowledged she did not love him, and yet he knew there was nothing he could do to change. He turned away from her and took another step toward the ledge.

"I'll make the pain go away," she yelled.

Swanson recalls this was "gold" to his ears.

He stepped off the ledge, ran into her arms crying and lied, saying the therapy had worked.

His mother stopped taking him to therapy, and the family changed instantly.

"We could go out to eat as a family again. We could smile," Swanson said. "From then on I completely became their straight son."

Swanson's parents still believe they have a straight son. However, Swanson is a member of the local LGBTQI community, where he feels accepted. It was not always this way.

Upon his arrival at K-State, Swanson said he was unaware other homosexuals existed. After all, he had been told the government had eradicated them.

He fought his same-sex attractions at K-State and forced himself into a heterosexual relationship as a cover, should accusations begin to arise. But he avoided all physical contact, using Christian values as a reason for his celibate relationship.

"It's great because I was this Christian boy, so I wasn't supposed to be doing anything, and that was really helpful," Swanson said.

Dusty Garner, senior in political science, recalled when Swanson approached the local LGBTQI community. Garner is a local leader and advocate for the community.

"When he got here and found out that [there were gay people in the world], he was so stunned that he didn't know what to do," Garner said of his friend.

Indeed, Swanson said he was "socially stunned" there was a gay community of people who led fulfilled lives.

One day on campus, Swanson overheard Chelsey Fritch, senior in humanities, talking about her girlfriend.

"We had talked a few times in the past, but we really got close during that awful winter break," Fritch said. "I had come out the year before that winter break and had quite an awful experience in coming out, being from a very similar religious background."

Fritch said she knew Swanson was gay from the moment they met.

"I could just see the inner turmoil that I had so familiarly experienced in the past," Fritch said. "What I did offer him was a shoulder to cry on and an ear to listen. I told him that being gay wasn't a choice; that it was only a part of what made him the amazing person he is today."

Fritch told him there were other gay people in the world and the government was not eradicating homosexuals, like his parents had told him.

Swanson said he began to "freak out." This revelation devastated him: All the people he had lived with and put his trust in had lied his entire life.

Swanson said Fritch was shocked that he believed he had AIDS.

Swanson said he began going through "un-therapy, going through all these stages, literally going through mental and physical, in reverse."

Through patience and understanding, Swanson said the gay community helped him understand that being gay was OK.

He said he feels he still has a lot of "un-therapy" to go through.

"I've never dated in the gay direction because I always wonder how the therapy will come back up," Swanson said. "Because every single time there is a major victory, I'm still having the nightmares."

Swanson expects the effects of his therapy to haunt him for life.

"I've literally had licensed psychologists say, ‘You need to repress this. This is so damaging we have no idea how you've gotten through this. This is not to be dealt with,'" he said.

Swanson said he was able to forgive the man who facilitated the therapy because he feels the man was not acting out of maliciousness. The man's actions were methodical, almost scientific; he told Swanson what would happen prior to each session.

"For him, you have to forgive someone that does such torturous things to be able to live," Swanson said. "He was hurting me, but he wasn't what I was concentrating on. I kept trying to focus on getting attracted to girls so this would stop."

Swanson said he even forgives his parents for putting him through a torturous 18-month period.

"I have forgiven them, but that doesn't mean I understand them," he said. "I don't understand how you can do that to a child."

He said his parents truly felt he was an abomination and simply wanted to see him go to heaven. He said his parents' drastic steps caused him inner conflict, and he hopes others can avoid his fate.

The American Psychological Association acknowledges the conflict that certain religious perspectives might present to parents with a homosexual child but urges parents not to take any action to change their child's sexuality.

The 2009 APA resolution on appropriate affirmative responses advises families "to avoid sexual orientation change efforts that portray homosexuality as a mental illness or developmental disorder, and to seek psychotherapy, social support and educational services" that provide accurate information on sexual orientation and sexuality.

Additionally, it recommends an increase in family and school support, to reduce rejection of "sexual minority youth."

"I stand one-million-and-one percent against it. It did not change me," Swanson said. "I look at it like I live in a world where God doesn't judge me for who I am, and he loves the world, so I'm going to help spread the word of his love, and that's how I move forward."

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

29 comments

Willie Wildcat
Mon Dec 21 2009 19:48
I am totally disgusted that a KState therapist would do such a filthy thing, as to enable perverted homosexual behaviour and thinking. This kid just doesn't remember how he "became a homosexual". He has repressed and denied what happened to him. Homosexuality is a learned behaviour, which comes by means of propaganda such as this article promulgated by homosexuals and their sympathizers. It comes by means of child abuse, rape, and by seduction. Homosexuals cannot reproduce, so they recruit the youth. Children are very vulnerable to such tactics. The American Psychiatric Association always held that homosexuality was a form of mental illness, until they got tired of their meetings being picketed and lobbied by those of the homo agenda, and they finally voted to say it wasn't a mental illness. Certainly mental illness is part of the consequences of this abominable behaviour, and the abuse which led to it.
Your name
Fri Dec 11 2009 22:22
HA! We are bigots because we refuse to believe this tripe without any proof?
Your name
Fri Dec 11 2009 12:59
For the people doubting the truth of the story: do you not understand the concept of anonymity? The guy obviously wants his privacy protected for various reasons. If you're curious about the use of shock therapy to essentially torture gays, then do a basic google search and do some reading. The Collegian writers may not have much to work with in terms of names, dates, and places.

Looking over the comments: you all are trying to mask your bigotry under a fake guise of "critical thinking." I can see through it and almost everyone here can.

cool story, bro
Thu Dec 10 2009 22:54
I'll believe this is real as soon as you give us some names and dates.
Your name
Thu Dec 10 2009 18:18
Thank God I am NOT a Christian!
Your name
Thu Dec 10 2009 18:13
My comment was apparently removed. But here's the jist of what my reply was:

Read more books eh? I read plenty of books, and do so gladly. The books I read, however, cite their sources, and have indisputable facts within their pages. This article, and the series, does not. The collegian should have some integrity and print only what it can prove.

Yes, life is so terrible for Homosexuals. We get it. Boohoo and all, but seriously. I will not buy into a story like this unless there is at the very least, a shred of evidence to back it up. Will you believe anything that reinforces your view of how the world is?

What is most disturbing, is your last sentence..."Even if this particular story was made up, I assure you, it's true for others..."
What you're saying is "I don't care if this story isn't true...because I know it happens elsewhere".

First of all, It does matter a lot if this is made up. What little that remains of the integrity of the Collegian would be gone, and I'm sure there's got to be some kind of law against making things up and publishing them. Second of all, I think it says a lot about you, that you could care less if this story is true or not. Push agendas much?

Your name
Thu Dec 10 2009 13:48
The Ironic thing, saddened, is in these history books, there is proof that atrocities and torture took place. There are actual names, places, dates, etc. In this article, there are none.

You accuse me of making "ignorant guesses", HA! Look up the word Ignorant, and that's exactly what the Collegian wants us to be apparently... Ignorant of the truth. Ignorant of the facts. This story may very well be true, but the Collegian has gone well out of it's way to hide the facts, to the point of making this story and series a journalistic joke. No other newspaper in the country would be stupid enough to print such unsubstantiated rubbish. You can drone all day about how bad the gay people of America have it, I could care less. It doesn't make this article any more credible than it was before you started playing your violin of sadness. The fact you "assure me" that even if this story is not true, it is true for others just shows me that you don't even care if it's true. That is what is most sickening. You could care less if it's true or not because you THINK that it MIGHT have happened. Open your eyes sheep.

Saddened
Thu Dec 10 2009 11:43
Dear "I could crap a more credible article" -

You should read more books. History is filled with examples of people being persecuted, tortured, and even killed because they were were different in some way: black, gay, female, believed to be a witch, etc. We've made great strides in this country, trying to see that everyone is treated fairly - except gay people. They are a minority among minorities, and crimes done to them are not only tolerated, but sometimes encouraged, including by the law.

How many gay people do you know personally? Maybe if you actually took the time to talk to some, you'd understand what life is like for them, instead of making ignorant guesses. I've spoken with many gay people, and it's alarming how many of them were mercilessly beaten and tortured by their own families because of the way they are. Even if this particular story was made up, I assure you, it's true for others.

I could crap a more credible article
Thu Dec 10 2009 01:18
So we are to believe anything any newspaper spits out with anonymous sources, with absolutely no credible information, and without any reason to actually think for a second it is true? It's such a bad peice of journalism it's almost sickening. The worst part is, you expect us to bite, hook line and sinker into it. If it's true, then, goodness give us some sign that you didn't make it all up. Let us check SOME facts. There are no CREDIBLE FACTS in this article. We are not sheeple, get used to it.
Your name
Thu Dec 10 2009 00:10
After reading all of the comments about people wanting to know what organization is doing this and how they want the name of the therapist, there is good reason as to why The Collegian does not release this information.

First, if they were to name any names, and these parties were to find out they were named, the therapist and organization could deny these claims and then sue for defamation of character, emotional abuse and the like. While Swanson could prove that he was tortured, some of these places have iron fist lawyers who could get them out of everything (example: Fred Phelps camp has rarely been sued and most people agree that they are terrible for their actions).

Secondly, just because someone does not give their real name or more details does not mean that it was made up. Honestly, if you were put in a terrible situation like this, your first thought is probably not "What is this guys name so I can remember it?" For most people, their basic instinct is to figure out how to make the pain stop. Swanson was lying to his parents that he had changed so the torture would quit. He probably just wanted to take that first step to make it stop.

Your name
Wed Dec 9 2009 15:23
The lack of journalistic professionalism in these articles is astounding.

They refuse to name anyone, any institution, or anything at all. We are supposed to sit back and just trust the collegian? I need to know facts. I don't need to know horror stories that are just as likely to be fiction as they are fact. No. Strike that. There is NO proof at all that this is true. Give me some friggin facts!

Fred Nek
Wed Dec 9 2009 00:32
Unless someone sues the "therapist", this sort of hell will continue. Forgive him? Fine, but you should still sue and collect, or the evil will continue.
Your name
Tue Dec 8 2009 22:51
Bash Back, it might be obvious for many of us to expect and want Swanson to fight back and attack his parents and especially the unnamed therapist. However, having come to know someone that was extensively sexually abused as a child, things are not always so simple with trauma and victimization. Maybe in time he will have the desire to fight back and maybe telling his story to the world is the first step in that direction, but often times there can be nothing better for the individual than simply listening. It can be really hard to just listen. I know that this someone that was sexually abused found it very difficult to open up to other people about what happened, not because he was unwilling to tell other people, but because people are unwilling to listen intently and compassionately to the uncomfortable, disgusting, horrifying, and gut wrenching details of his abuse. Listening to someone recount how they were first raped at 7 years old is more than a little hard. It is hard to not react with anger, judgement, and place your own expectation on the victim. It could even be the case that Swanson identifies and sympathizes with those responsible for his torture. Whatever the case might be, we must not make the situation worse just to make ourselves feel better or more comfortable.
Bash Back!
Tue Dec 8 2009 20:37
what happened to media being a watchdog? You should speak with Thomas and tell him how important it is to out the organizations that did this to him. There are still kids going through the same things today. If he wants to save them he needs to speak out. He could be saving lives by doing so.
Roger Eddit
Tue Dec 8 2009 19:21
Please identify the treatment person and center.
Bill
Tue Dec 8 2009 19:15
I don't doubt that terrible things happen in the name of conversion therapy, but I too have my suspicions about the veracity of this story. The "forgotten" name of the therapist is very convenient, preventing anyone from taking any action against this therapist. I seriously doubt that anyone would forget the name of their torturer... especially after going to him for 18 months. Certainly Thomas can remember the location of where the therapy took place. A simple Google search ought to deliver the information. If these events did indeed happen, Thomas has a moral obligation to hand this so-call therapist over to the authorities.

Although fundamentalists are suspicious of the government, they usually believe it's because they are falling away from biblical principles. The story of the government eradicating gays seems contrary to that position.

Finally, I don't buy that such a heavily cloistered, home schooled student would be allowed to attend a "secular" school like Kansas State... especially if that student is still closeted and within the fold of their parents' faith.

Sorry to be the skeptic. But if we're going to win the battle for gay rights, we have to do it with truth... not made-up stories.

James U
Tue Dec 8 2009 17:51
there is no doubt in my mind it is possible. look at the hard core muslims that have cut heads off. and i have seen the folks on tv in the streets screaming "god hates faggs". but i just question it. and there was one comment in the list that suggest thinking it was fake was some kind of homophobic reaction. i can acknowledge that as a possibility, but they can't acknowledge this being fake, as a possibility.

here is one thing that screams at me. you have parents that home school a kid. he is so tightly controlled that he doesn't even know there are other gay people in the world. so after all this complete control, they send him to k-state? does anyone else see the problem with this? and how did he seek out the gay lesbien transblah blah blah group, if he didn't think they even existed? you could say he found out about them on campus i guess. but then you have to ask yourself why find them, if you are convinced the government is killing them all? being a homophober may be why i question all this. it may also be, deductive reasoning.

Your name
Tue Dec 8 2009 16:45
Andrew, who is claiming that the issue here is about being "born gay." Might you pause for a moment and find compassion for someone who was tortured before pushing for the same sense of morality that ultimately led to this suffering?
Your name
Tue Dec 8 2009 15:44
Hi Andrew -- just to check: does this mean that you support marriage equality, i.e., same-sex marriage? Otherwise, you're putting gay people in a bind that straight people don't have to deal with.
Andrew Casey
Tue Dec 8 2009 15:12
Whether or not people are "born gay" is not the issue. Being born with a certain tendancy toward a specific action does not make that action right or wrong. All people have the ability and responsibility to choose their actions regardless of what their desires might be. As a Christian, I will also say that sin is sin. Homosexual immorality is no more wrong than heterosexual immorality. The bottom line is, if a person is not married, they should not be sexually active. We can choose to do the right thing regardless of how we feel. It is ACTIONS that are sinful, not a persons feelings or temptations.






log out