Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Current policy discriminates against Gays

Published: Tuesday, October 13, 2009

Updated: Tuesday, October 13, 2009 07:10

Molly McGuire

Molly McGuire

There are people who are willing to die for you. They are willing to put their lives on the line to serve and protect our country. While many patriotic Americans have the desire, the will and the drive to serve in the U.S. military, they are banned from doing so simply because of their sexual orientation. According to an American Progress report, more than 13,000 homosexual service members have been discharged from the military since 1993.
President Obama rearticulated his support for the repeal of the "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" policy at Saturday's Human Rights Campaign event, which focused on equal rights for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender Americans.

"I am working with the Pentagon, its leadership and members of the House and Senate to end this policy," he said at the campaign. "I will end ‘Don't Ask, Don't Tell.' That is my commitment to you."

This is an ambitious promise to make, yet it is a crucial one that will promote equality and effectiveness within our military.

We have treated LGBT members of our community as second class citizens for too long with laws that prevent them from marrying their significant others and allowing them to serve within our military. Our policies are not upholding the fundamental beliefs of our Founding Fathers: All men are created equal.

This sense of equality within our society is essential to ensure that all people contribute to the community. When people no longer find a connection to their community, they see no need to give back, leaving it only focused on individual benefits and not allowing for progress.

With our military fighting on two fronts and our service members returning for second and third tours in Iraq and Afghanistan, the exclusion of willing and capable Americans is absurd. Take the story of Dan, recounted to "VetVoice: The Voice of America's 21st Century Patriots." Dan graduated from West Point Military Academy with a degree in Arabic, and he is a combat veteran of Iraq. During his tour in Iraq, he wasn't allowed to express himself as a gay. When he came out of the closet, he was no longer allowed to serve in the U.S. military.

While Dan was fluent in Arabic, something that obviously would be particularly beneficial during a war in the Middle East, the ‘Don't Ask, Don't Tell' policy stopped him from continuing his necessary service as a translator.

Even if homosexual service members do not speak a foreign language, their service to our country is greatly needed in our current military commitment around the world. Instead of sending our overworked service members back, we could relieve them with one of the 13,000 who have been discharged from our military.

One of the main concerns against removing the policy is troop morale and effectiveness. It has been empirically proven that this is not true. According to the Palm Center, the 24 other countries that allow homosexuals to serve in their country's military have not seen a decline in morale, or quality of their forces.

The center's Web site states, "In the more than three decades since an overseas force first allowed gay men and lesbians to serve openly, no study has ever documented any detriment to cohesion, readiness, recruiting, morale, retention or any other measure of effectiveness or quality in foreign armed services."

With all that being said, let's fight for those who are willing to fight for us and help President Obama repeal "Don't Ask, Don't Tell."

 

-Molly McGuire is a sophomore in political science and speech. Please send comments to opinion@spub.ksu.edu.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

7 comments

Bill
Mon Nov 30 2009 22:34
I'm sorry my post was incomplete...the problem with having gays in the military is that it may lead to the possibility of love relationships getting in the way of the mission. Sorry I didn't post this correctly.

Thank you for writing the article.

Bill
Mon Nov 30 2009 22:28
I know that you mean well, but you are off the mark. Most civilians don't understand why the military maintains barriers between officers and enlisted men and why personnel of all ranks are transferred on a regular basis. It's because the military and the mission come before people and relationships. People can't stay in place too long otherwise the human element (even normal platonic, straight relationships) may get in the way of the mission. Believe me, I'm not anti-gay. Prior to attending K-State I served in the Army for the College Fund (1st Infantry Division). So, I feel like I know something about the subject matter. The military exists to deal with something really, really horrible. War. It's not about using the military to support a social agenda.
Elizabeth
Mon Oct 19 2009 17:11
Thank you for writing this!! I wholeheartedly agree.
Cate
Wed Oct 14 2009 16:49
Very well put James Duffy!
Your name
Tue Oct 13 2009 15:53
it's actually a shame that this issue has drawn up such controversy. You'd think that the men/women defending our country would be mature enough to ignore something like that; apparently they aren't. GLBT people are just as capable of being in the military as any other person.
Aaron
Tue Oct 13 2009 12:40
Agree Don't Ask Don't Tell is ridiculous policy, but how about we just end marriage. I don't understand why people are stil so wrapped up in this institution that is completely unnecessary. Marriage = the professional prostitution of women.
James Duffy
Tue Oct 13 2009 11:00
Here's what gets me: You take a rough, tough, heterosexual farmboy from somewhere in Middle America, put him through the rigors of basic training, chew him up, spit him out, and mold him into the perfect killing machine ready and willing to run into a hail of bullets at the drop of a hat ... BUT: Confront that same hard guy with the possibility that he just might have to share a barracks with a Gay soldier, and he just falls to pieces. Go figure.






log out